Книга о дурной аргументации

[mancunian1998]

https://bookofbadarguments.com/

Очень хорошая! В ней собраны все логические кульбиты, которые мы так часто встречаем в этих наших интернетах и даже в RL. Запомните их все и мочите ваших оппонентов скриншотами!

Comments

[leblon.livejournal.com]

Объяснения хорошие, картинки плохие.

[mancunian.livejournal.com]

Не все удачные, согласен. Слишком много текста для картинок. Вот, кстати, этот фрагмент про кофе в старбаксе для протестеров:

[occuserpens.livejournal.com]

Точно сказано об использовании этой ссылки в этом ЖЖ:

Appeal to Irrelevant Authority
An appeal to authority is an appeal to one's sense of modesty [Engel], which is to say, an appeal to the feeling that others are more knowledgeable. The overwhelming majority of the things that we believe in, such as atoms and the solar system, are on reliable authority, as are all historical statements, to paraphrase C. S. Lewis. One may reasonably appeal to pertinent authority, as scientists and academics typically do. An argument becomes fallacious when the appeal is to an authority who is not an expert on the issue at hand. A similar appeal worth noting is the appeal to vague authority, where an idea is attributed to a vague collective. For example, Professors in Germany showed such and such to be true.

A type of appeal to irrelevant authority is the appeal to ancient wisdom, where something is assumed to be true just because it was believed to be true some time ago. For example, Astrology was practiced by technologically advanced civilizations such as the Ancient Chinese. Therefore, it must be true. One might also appeal to ancient wisdom to support things that are idiosyncratic, or that may change with time. For example, People used to sleep for nine hours a night many centuries ago, therefore we need to sleep for that long these days as well. There are all sorts of reasons that may have caused people to sleep for longer periods of time in the past. The fact that they did provides no evidence for the argument.

[mancunian.livejournal.com]

Look what the cat dragged.